HOAs in Arizona — The Scale and Landscape You Need to Understand
Arizona has approximately 9,600 homeowners associations statewide — more than any state except California and Florida, and a remarkable number given Arizona's relatively modest total population. Maricopa County alone is home to more than 6,000 HOAs. This density reflects decades of master-planned development in the Phoenix metro, where nearly every new community built from the late 1990s onward has been organized under an HOA structure. The result: approximately 50% of all Arizona single-family homes are located in an HOA-governed community.
Understanding Arizona HOA law is not optional knowledge for Phoenix metro buyers and sellers — it is essential. The HOA governing documents on a home you purchase are legally binding contracts that run with the land. They affect what you can do with your home, what you must pay, and what the community can do to you if you fail to comply. Treating HOA review as a checkbox item rather than a genuine due diligence exercise is one of the most common and costly mistakes buyers make in Arizona real estate.
Two Types of Arizona HOA: Planned Community vs Condominium
Arizona law recognizes two distinct types of HOA, each governed by a separate statute:
- Planned Community HOA (ARS Title 33, Chapter 16, beginning at ARS §33-1801): Governs HOAs in planned developments of single-family homes, townhomes, and similar individual-lot properties. This is the most common HOA type in Phoenix metro and the primary focus of this guide. The HOA owns and maintains common areas; individual homeowners own their lots and structures.
- Condominium HOA (ARS Title 33, Chapter 9, beginning at ARS §33-1201): Governs condominium associations where unit owners hold undivided interests in the common elements of a building. Different fee structures, different maintenance responsibilities, and different legal rules than planned community HOAs.
Both types must comply with Arizona Open Meeting Law (HOA boards must conduct open meetings accessible to members), have similar assessment collection rules, and both are subject to the Arizona Department of Real Estate's HOA dispute oversight process. When people in Phoenix talk about "HOA communities," they are almost always referring to planned community HOAs governed by ARS §33-1801 et seq.
How HOA Membership Works: It Is Automatic and Mandatory
In a planned community with a mandatory HOA, membership is not optional. When you purchase a home in that community, you automatically become a member of the HOA and subject to its governing documents — regardless of whether you were informed in advance, whether you agreed explicitly, or whether you want to participate. The CC&Rs are recorded documents that run with the land. They bind every subsequent owner of each lot. There is no mechanism to opt out of membership in a mandatory HOA community. This is one of the most important facts for buyers to understand before making an offer on an HOA property.
HOA Fees in Phoenix Metro — What They Cover and What They Cost
HOA fees in Arizona planned communities range from under $50 per month in minimal communities to over $2,000 per month in ultra-luxury gated estates. The fee level is determined by the depth and cost of the amenities provided, the scope of maintenance services included, the community's infrastructure obligations, and the adequacy of reserve fund contributions. Understanding what a given HOA fee actually buys — and how to evaluate whether it is reasonable — is an important part of the buying decision.
What HOA Fees Cover: The Required Budget Breakdown
By Arizona law, the HOA must prepare and distribute an itemized annual budget. Arizona HOA fees typically fund some or all of the following:
- Common area maintenance: Landscaping, irrigation, hardscape repair, and general upkeep of community common areas including parks, medians, and entryways.
- Amenity operations and maintenance: Pool and spa maintenance and lifeguarding (if applicable); fitness center equipment; clubhouse utilities and upkeep; tennis, pickleball, or basketball courts.
- Insurance: Property and liability insurance on common-area structures and facilities. Note that individual homeowner properties are NOT covered by HOA insurance — you need your own homeowner's policy.
- Management company fees: Approximately 50%–70% of Arizona HOAs use professional management companies (FirstService Residential, Associa, CCMC, Russ Lyon Realty Management, and others). Management fees typically represent 20%–35% of total assessments.
- Administrative and compliance costs: Document management, violation processing, legal compliance, member communications, board support.
- Reserve fund contribution: Funds set aside for future major capital expenditures identified in the reserve study. Arizona law requires planned communities to maintain reserve funds and conduct periodic reserve studies.
Phoenix Metro HOA Fee Ranges by Community Type
| Community Type | Typical Monthly HOA Fee | What's Included | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimal (streets, no amenities) | $30–$80/mo | Street lighting, common area maintenance, basic admin | Many Queen Creek and Coolidge entry-level communities |
| Standard (pool, park, playground) | $80–$180/mo | Community pool, parks, common landscaping, management | Most Gilbert, Chandler, and Mesa master-planned communities |
| Resort-Style (multiple pools, fitness, clubhouse) | $200–$500/mo | Multiple pools, fitness center, clubhouse, guard gate option | Power Ranch (Gilbert), Vistancia (Peoria), Eastmark (Mesa) |
| Luxury Gated | $500–$2,000+/mo | Full-service guard gate, extensive amenities, premium maintenance | Silverleaf, DC Ranch premium sections, Estancia (Scottsdale) |
| Active Adult / 55+ Communities | $400–$1,500/mo | All exterior maintenance, golf (some), pools, activity centers | Sun Lakes, Sun City Grand, Trilogy communities |
| High-Rise Condo HOA | $400–$1,800+/mo | Building maintenance, insurance, amenities, water/sewer often included | Scottsdale Waterfront, various Downtown Phoenix condos |
When evaluating homes in HOA communities, always add the HOA fee to the mortgage payment, property taxes, and homeowner's insurance to get your true total monthly housing cost. A home with a $2,800/month mortgage and a $350/month HOA has a $3,150+ effective monthly housing payment. Buyers who focus only on the mortgage payment routinely underestimate total HOA carrying costs — and are surprised when their lender's debt-to-income calculation includes the HOA fee as a recurring obligation.
Arizona HOA Law Basics — ARS §33-1801 and What It Requires
The Arizona Planned Community Act (ARS §33-1801 et seq.) is the primary statutory framework governing planned community HOAs in Arizona. Every buyer and owner in an HOA community should understand the core provisions of this law because it establishes both the HOA's powers and your rights as a homeowner. It is not the HOA's internal rulebook — it is the state law that overrides any conflicting HOA governing document.
Open Meetings (ARS §33-1804): HOA board meetings must be open to all members of the association, with limited exceptions for executive sessions covering litigation, personnel matters, or collections. Members have the right to attend, observe, and record meetings. The HOA cannot hold secret board meetings. Agendas must be provided in advance where practicable.
Budget and Financial Transparency (ARS §33-1803): The HOA board must prepare an annual budget and distribute it to all members. Members have the right to review the budget and, in some circumstances, to call for a vote to reject the proposed budget and require a revised one. The HOA must maintain financial records accessible to members.
Assessment Caps: Unlike some states, Arizona does NOT statutorily cap the amount by which HOA assessments can increase year-over-year. HOAs can increase fees significantly with appropriate board action and member notice. Review the CC&Rs for any community-specific caps on annual increases — some HOAs have written in their own caps.
Fine Limits and Due Process (ARS §33-1803.02): The HOA may assess fines for CC&R violations, but must provide notice and an opportunity to cure before a fine becomes effective. Starting fines are typically $25–$100 per violation and can escalate for continuing violations. The member has the right to request a hearing before the fine becomes final.
Lien and Foreclosure Authority (ARS §33-1807): The HOA may record a lien on any lot for unpaid assessments, fines, and costs of collection. The HOA may foreclose on that lien if not satisfied. This is the most serious enforcement mechanism available to Arizona HOAs.
Key Homeowner Rights Under Arizona HOA Law
Arizona law provides several specific protections for HOA members that are worth knowing before you purchase in an HOA community:
- American flag display (ARS §33-1261): Arizona prohibits HOAs from restricting the display of the American flag or the flag of the United States Armed Forces branches. No HOA rule can prevent you from displaying an American flag.
- Political signs: Arizona has specific statutory protections for political sign display on private property during election periods; HOA rules that completely prohibit political signs may conflict with state law.
- Solar energy systems (ARS §33-1816): Arizona prohibits HOAs from prohibiting the installation of solar energy systems on residential property, though the HOA can place reasonable requirements on installation location and aesthetics.
- Hearing rights: Before any HOA fine becomes effective, you have the right to request and receive a hearing before the board (ARS §33-1803). This right must be exercised in writing.
- Document access: Members have the right to inspect and copy HOA financial records and meeting minutes upon written request (ARS §33-1805).
- Disclosure rights: Sellers are required by law to disclose HOA existence and provide governing documents to buyers during escrow (ARS §33-1806). This is a statutory obligation, not just a custom.
CC&Rs — What They Are, What They Restrict, and Why They Matter
CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) are recorded legal documents filed with the county recorder that establish the rules governing a planned community. They are not the HOA's internal policy manual — they are recorded encumbrances that run with the land, binding every owner and every subsequent buyer of every lot in the community. The word "run with the land" is the critical phrase: when you purchase a home in an HOA community, you accept the CC&Rs as part of the title. You cannot avoid them by not reading them. You cannot bargain them away. They are part of what you are buying.
CC&Rs are supplemented by the HOA's bylaws (which govern the HOA's internal operating structure) and the HOA's rules and regulations (which provide more detailed guidance on day-to-day compliance requirements). Together, these three documents — CC&Rs, bylaws, and rules and regulations — constitute the governing documents that control life in an HOA community.
Common CC&R Restrictions in Arizona HOA Communities
While every HOA has unique CC&Rs, certain restriction categories appear in virtually every Arizona planned community HOA:
The most commonly enforced category of CC&R restriction. Most Arizona HOAs require Architectural Review Committee (ARC) approval before any exterior modification to the home or lot. Common requirements include:
- Paint colors limited to a HOA-approved palette (repainting to an unapproved color requires ARC approval)
- ARC approval required for new fences, walls, or modifications to existing fencing
- ARC approval required for patio covers, pergolas, awnings, and outdoor structures
- ARC approval required for additions to the home structure
- Solar panel installation subject to ARC approval on location and aesthetic standards (though prohibition is illegal per ARS §33-1816)
- Landscaping modifications in front yard or visible side yards often require ARC approval
Key practice point: Always submit ARC applications before starting exterior work, not after. Retroactive approval is not guaranteed, and completed work that violates CC&Rs may require removal at the homeowner's expense.
Vehicle restrictions are among the most frequently contested HOA issues in Phoenix metro communities. Standard restrictions in Arizona HOAs typically include:
- Prohibition on overnight street parking of commercial vehicles, RVs, boats, trailers, and oversized vehicles
- Prohibition on RV, boat, and trailer storage in driveways or side yards visible from the street
- Requirements that garage doors remain closed except when in active use
- Prohibition on parking inoperable or unregistered vehicles in driveways
- Limitations on number of vehicles parked in driveway
Buyer caution: If you own an RV, boat, commercial vehicle, or work truck that you park at home, review the CC&Rs for vehicle provisions before purchasing in any HOA community. These are among the most aggressively enforced restrictions in the Phoenix metro market. Some communities have dedicated RV storage lots; others have no accommodation whatsoever.
Rental restrictions in Arizona HOAs have become one of the most dynamic and consequential areas of CC&R law as short-term rentals have grown. The current landscape as of 2026:
- Some HOAs: no rental restrictions (any rental, any term)
- Some HOAs: registration requirement (register tenant with HOA; no substantive restriction)
- Some HOAs: minimum rental term requirement (30, 60, or 90 days — effectively prohibits STR while allowing long-term rental)
- Some HOAs: total prohibition on rentals (more common in condo HOAs; relatively rare in single-family planned community HOAs)
- Some HOAs: percentage cap on rentals (e.g., maximum 25% of homes in community may be rented at any time)
Critical distinction: ARS §9-500.39 limits cities from broadly banning short-term rentals, but HOA CC&Rs can independently restrict or prohibit STR. A property in a city without an STR ordinance can still be prohibited from STR by its HOA CC&Rs. City law and HOA rules are independent — the more restrictive of the two governs your property.
Arizona's desert climate creates specific HOA landscaping dynamics that differ from most other states. Common restrictions:
- Front yard must be maintained to community standard (defined in CC&Rs or rules)
- Some communities require traditional turf grass; others mandate or strongly encourage xeriscape; some allow either
- Specific plant species may be prohibited (invasive species restrictions) or required (desert-appropriate plants lists)
- Weed control requirements — typically enforced spring through fall
- Specific mulch, rock, or ground cover requirements in front yard
- Seasonal decoration restrictions (holiday lights timing and removal requirements)
- Tree pruning and maintenance standards, including visibility-blocking restrictions near streets and intersections
Landscaping violations are among the most common HOA enforcement issues in Arizona, particularly in spring when growth is rapid and visual standards are most obvious from the street.
Ryan recommends that every buyer purchasing in an HOA community take the time to actually read the CC&Rs and rules and regulations — not just skim them. If any provision is unclear or seems potentially problematic for your intended use of the property, ask a real estate attorney to review that specific section before removing contingencies. The cost of a one-hour attorney review is trivial compared to the cost of discovering post-close that your intended use of the property is prohibited by the CC&Rs. Ryan flags the most common high-risk provisions (vehicle storage, rental restrictions, ARC requirements, pet rules) for every buyer as part of HOA document review.
Buyer Rights During Escrow — HOA Disclosure and Document Review
Arizona law creates specific rights for buyers during the escrow period to review HOA documents and make an informed decision before committing to purchase. Understanding these rights — and the timeline for exercising them — is essential for any buyer purchasing in an HOA community.
What Sellers Must Disclose Under ARS §33-1806
The Arizona Planned Community Act requires sellers to provide buyers with a comprehensive HOA disclosure package. The seller must deliver or make available:
- A copy of the CC&Rs, bylaws, and rules and regulations currently in effect
- A copy of the most recent financial statements, including an income statement and balance sheet
- The most recent reserve study (or a summary of it)
- The current annual budget
- Notice of any pending assessments (special assessments approved by the board but not yet levied)
- Notice of any known outstanding violations on the specific property being sold
- Contact information for the HOA management company or board
The seller typically orders this HOA disclosure package from the management company at a cost of $200–$600 (paid by the seller per Arizona custom). Delivery typically takes 3–10 business days, which is why the HOA document review period in an Arizona residential purchase contract begins from the date of document delivery, not from the contract date.
What Buyers Should Look For in HOA Documents
Most buyers receive a stack of documents and do not know what to focus on. Ryan reviews HOA documents with every buyer and specifically flags these high-risk items:
A special assessment is a one-time charge the HOA levies on all owners for a capital expense not fully covered by the reserve fund. Examples: pool replastering, roof replacement on clubhouse, road resurfacing, major litigation costs. Special assessments can range from a few hundred dollars to $30,000+ per home depending on the scope of the project and the community's size.
The seller's disclosure must include any pending special assessment — meaning an assessment that has been approved but not yet levied on owners. If you close before the assessment is levied, you become responsible for the full amount even though it was approved before your purchase. This is a major risk if not discovered during document review.
- Ask specifically: "Has any special assessment been approved by the board in the last 12 months?"
- If a special assessment is pending, negotiate who pays it (seller or buyer)
- The amount should be material enough to warrant a price adjustment if seller won't cover it
The reserve fund is the HOA's savings account for future major capital expenditures. A well-funded reserve dramatically reduces the risk of a future special assessment. The reserve study (which Arizona HOAs are required to maintain) calculates the percentage of funding recommended vs. actual funds on hand. Interpreting this number:
- 90%+ funded: very healthy; low special assessment risk
- 70%–89% funded: adequate; moderate special assessment risk
- 50%–69% funded: underfunded; elevated special assessment risk
- Below 50% funded: seriously underfunded; high special assessment risk within 5–10 years
A severely underfunded reserve does not necessarily kill the deal, but it should factor into your offer price and your expected total cost of ownership over time. Buyers with financing should also note that severely underfunded HOA reserves can affect Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac loan eligibility for condominiums (less commonly for planned communities).
If the HOA is involved in significant litigation — whether as plaintiff or defendant — this can affect property values, community finances, and financing eligibility. Common HOA litigation scenarios:
- Construction defect claims against the developer (common in newer Arizona communities; if pending, watch for a potential large settlement that results in a special assessment or fund injection)
- Neighbor vs HOA disputes that have escalated to litigation
- HOA vs external party litigation (slip-and-fall claims, contractor disputes)
- Builder transition disputes (HOA suing the developer over incomplete common area improvements)
The financial statements and any notes to the financial statements should disclose material pending litigation. For condo purchases specifically, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have specific rules about HOA litigation that can affect whether a loan is eligible for conventional financing.
The HOA's delinquency rate — the percentage of homeowners who are delinquent on assessments — is an indicator of both community financial health and neighborhood stability. High delinquency strains the HOA's budget, can reduce reserve contributions, and can affect financing.
- For condominium HOAs: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require delinquency below 15% of units for a project to maintain "warrantable" status. Above 15%, conventional financing may be unavailable on the entire project.
- For planned community HOAs: delinquency rules are less strict for conventional financing but still affect HOA financial health.
- A delinquency rate above 10% in any HOA raises concerns about budget stress and potential fee increases.
- The financial statements (accounts receivable section) will show total delinquent assessments; calculate as a percentage of total homes to estimate the delinquency rate.
Special Assessments — The Hidden HOA Cost That Surprises Most Buyers
Special assessments are one of the most significant and most underappreciated risks in Arizona HOA homeownership. A special assessment is a one-time, per-unit charge levied by the HOA board to fund a capital expenditure or extraordinary expense that cannot be fully covered by the existing reserve fund. Unlike regular monthly assessments (which are predictable and budgeted), special assessments arrive unexpectedly — sometimes with very short notice — and can represent thousands of dollars in additional housing cost that a buyer did not anticipate at the time of purchase.
Common Causes of Special Assessments in Phoenix Metro HOAs
- Pool replastering: Major community pools typically require replastering every 8–12 years at a cost that may require a special assessment in underfunded communities.
- Common area roof replacement: Clubhouse and covered pavilion roofs in Phoenix's intense sun environment have relatively short lifespans; replacement costs can be $200,000+ for larger clubhouses.
- Road resurfacing within community: Private community streets require periodic resurfacing; a large community may face $500,000–$2,000,000 in road costs not fully covered by reserves.
- Major litigation costs: Construction defect settlements, slip-and-fall judgments, or major contractor disputes can result in unbudgeted legal costs.
- Emergency capital replacements: HVAC systems for clubhouses, elevator replacements in multi-story condos, major plumbing repairs to community infrastructure.
- Catch-up reserve contributions: A board that has historically kept assessments artificially low by underfunding reserves may eventually impose a special assessment to bring reserves to adequate levels.
The average special assessment in Arizona planned community HOAs ranges from $2,000–$15,000 per household. In condo communities with complex building systems, special assessments can exceed $30,000–$50,000 per unit for major projects. These are not rare events — they are a predictable consequence of inadequate reserve funding and aging community infrastructure.
How to Evaluate Special Assessment Risk Before Buying
Reserve fund funded at 70%+ of reserve study recommendation. Recent capital projects completed without special assessments. Stable or moderately increasing regular assessments (small regular increases fund reserves more sustainably than flat assessments). Professional management with transparent financial reporting. Reserve study completed within last 3 years. Low delinquency rate. No pending or recent major capital projects in the disclosure package.
Reserve fund below 50% funded. Assessments have been flat for 5+ years (artificially suppressed). Reserve study is outdated (more than 5 years old). Major community infrastructure (pool, roof, roads) approaching end of service life visible in documents. Active litigation that may result in an unexpected judgment. High delinquency rate stressing the operating budget. Community is 15–25 years old and entering its first major capital replacement cycle.
Of all the HOA documents provided during escrow, the reserve study contains the most decision-relevant information for evaluating long-term ownership costs. It tells you what major capital expenditures are expected, when they are projected, and whether the fund is adequate to cover them. If the reserve study is not included in the HOA disclosure package, request it specifically. If the HOA cannot produce a recent reserve study, that itself is a warning sign about the board's management quality and financial planning rigor.
HOA Violations, Fines, and Dispute Resolution — Your Rights When the HOA Comes Knocking
Receiving an HOA violation notice is one of the most stressful experiences in HOA homeownership. Understanding the standard enforcement process and your specific legal rights under Arizona law can significantly affect the outcome of any violation dispute — and knowing the process in advance reduces the anxiety of receiving that first notice.
The Standard HOA Violation and Fine Process in Arizona
- Written violation notice: The HOA sends a written notice identifying the specific CC&R or rule violation and providing a deadline for correction (typically 10–30 days). The notice should cite the specific provision violated.
- Cure period: The owner has until the deadline to correct the violation. If corrected within the cure period and no further violation occurs, the matter is typically closed with no fine.
- Fine assessment: If the violation is not corrected by the deadline, the HOA may assess a fine. Starting fines in most Arizona HOAs are $25–$100 per violation. Continuing violations may be fined on a daily or weekly basis and can escalate significantly.
- Collection and lien: If fines remain unpaid, the HOA can add collection costs, attorney's fees, and interest, and ultimately record a lien on the property against the accumulated balance.
- Foreclosure: Continued non-payment of fines and assessments can lead to HOA-initiated foreclosure under ARS §33-1807 — though this is rare for fine-only balances and far more common when assessments are also unpaid.
Your Rights When You Receive a Violation Notice
Under ARS §33-1803, you have a statutory right to request a hearing before any fine becomes effective. This right is critical and time-sensitive:
- Request the hearing in writing immediately after receiving the violation notice. Do not wait to see if the HOA follows up.
- The request must be in writing: verbal requests are insufficient and may be disregarded. Send written request via email to the management company and via certified mail to the HOA's registered address.
- The HOA must schedule and hold the hearing within a reasonable time period as specified in the CC&Rs or bylaws.
- At the hearing: present your case calmly and factually. Bring photos, documentation, ARC approval records, or any other evidence supporting your position.
- If you disagree with the board's decision: the CC&Rs may provide for mediation or arbitration as next steps. You can ultimately pursue the matter in Maricopa County Superior Court if necessary.
The Arizona Department of Real Estate HOA Dispute Process
Arizona established a formal HOA dispute process administered through the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE). The ADRE HOA Ombudsman can investigate complaints from HOA members about procedural violations by Arizona HOAs. This process is available to members who believe the HOA has violated Arizona law in its procedures — for example, holding closed meetings that should be open, failing to follow proper fine notice procedures, or refusing to provide documents members are entitled to receive.
Important limitations: the ADRE process is focused on procedural compliance, not substantive disputes about whether a CC&R provision is fair. The ADRE cannot order the HOA to pay you money damages, cannot force the HOA to change its CC&Rs, and cannot override the board's substantive decisions. But it can order the HOA to comply with procedural requirements and can issue findings against HOAs that repeatedly violate Arizona law — which is meaningful leverage in some situations.
The most important thing to do when you receive any HOA violation notice is to respond in writing and promptly. Silence is typically interpreted as acceptance. A polite, factual written response that requests a hearing, provides evidence supporting your position, and expresses willingness to resolve the matter cooperatively almost always produces a better outcome than ignoring the notice or engaging in verbal arguments. Ryan has seen many Arizona buyers navigate HOA issues successfully by being proactive, professional, and informed about their statutory rights under ARS §33-1803.
Rental Restrictions in Arizona HOAs — What Every Investor and Owner Must Know
Rental restrictions in Arizona HOA communities have become one of the most consequential and rapidly evolving areas of HOA law. As short-term rental activity expanded through Airbnb and VRBO in the 2015–2022 period, many Phoenix metro HOAs responded by amending their CC&Rs to restrict or prohibit rentals. Understanding the current landscape is essential for any buyer who anticipates renting the property — whether long-term, short-term, or as an occasional income supplement.
The Spectrum of Rental Restrictions in Phoenix Metro HOAs
There is no single standard for rental restrictions in Arizona HOAs — each community's CC&Rs are different. The range in practice:
| Restriction Type | What It Means | Long-Term Rental OK? | Short-Term Rental OK? |
|---|---|---|---|
| No rental restrictions | Any rental, any term, no approval needed | Yes | Yes |
| Registration requirement only | Must register tenant/guest with HOA; no substantive limit | Yes | Yes (register guest) |
| Minimum rental term (30 days) | No rental may be for less than 30 consecutive days | Yes | No |
| Minimum rental term (90 days) | No rental may be for less than 90 consecutive days | Yes | No |
| Cap on rental percentage | Maximum X% of homes may be rented at any time (20–25% typical) | Yes (if cap not full) | Varies |
| Total prohibition on rentals | No rentals of any kind permitted | No | No |
The City vs HOA Distinction: ARS §9-500.39
This is one of the most important legal distinctions buyers often misunderstand. Arizona state law (ARS §9-500.39) restricts municipalities from enacting blanket prohibitions on short-term rentals. However, this statute governs city and county ordinances — it does not override or preempt HOA CC&Rs. An HOA can independently restrict or prohibit short-term rentals through its CC&Rs regardless of what city law says. The two regulatory systems are independent.
Practical example: A home in Scottsdale (which has an STR licensing system but permits STR) that is in an HOA community with a 90-day minimum rental term cannot be used as an Airbnb rental — because the HOA CC&Rs prohibit it, even though Scottsdale city law would otherwise permit it. The more restrictive rule governs. Buyers who purchase in an HOA community assuming city STR permissiveness protects them are making a costly error.
Checking Rental Restrictions Before You Buy
For any buyer who anticipates renting the property — even occasionally, even years in the future — Ryan checks rental restrictions in HOA documents at the start of the escrow period, not as an afterthought. The questions to answer specifically:
- Do the CC&Rs contain any rental restriction provisions? If so, what exactly do they say?
- Is there a minimum rental term? What is it?
- Is there a registration or approval requirement for tenants or guests?
- Is there a percentage cap on rentals, and if so, is the community currently at or near the cap?
- Have there been any recent CC&R amendments related to rentals? (Recent amendments to add or tighten restrictions are often filed separately at the county recorder and may not appear prominently in the main CC&R document.)
HOA Liens and Foreclosure Risk — The Most Misunderstood and Serious HOA Issue
The single most consequential — and most widely misunderstood — aspect of Arizona HOA law is the HOA's foreclosure power. Many homeowners operate under the mistaken belief that as long as their mortgage is current, they cannot lose their home. Arizona law does not work that way. An HOA can foreclose on your home for unpaid assessments even if your mortgage lender has been paid every month on time.
The Statutory Authority: ARS §33-1807
Arizona Revised Statutes §33-1807 provides that the HOA has a lien on each lot for any unpaid assessments and charges. This lien may be recorded with the county recorder. ARS §33-1807(B) further provides that the association may foreclose on this lien in the same manner as a mortgage lien.
HOA liens are junior to first-mortgage liens in most cases (meaning the first mortgage lender's position is generally protected if the HOA forecloses and the property sells for less than the first mortgage balance). However, the homeowner has no such protection — they can lose the home entirely if the HOA lien is foreclosed and the sale price covers the HOA debt plus senior liens.
This foreclosure authority applies to unpaid assessments (regular HOA fees), unpaid fines, and the HOA's collection costs including attorney's fees. A homeowner who ignores HOA communications about unpaid balances risks losing their home in a timeline that is shorter than many people expect.
The HOA Foreclosure Process and Timeline
Arizona HOA foreclosure follows a process similar to non-judicial mortgage foreclosure but with some additional statutory requirements. The general timeline:
- Delinquency begins: Assessment payment is missed. HOA sends first notice of delinquency. Late fees begin accruing.
- Collection referral: After continued non-payment (typically 30–90 days), the account is referred to the HOA's collection attorney. Attorney fees begin accruing and are added to the balance.
- Lien recording: The HOA records a lien at the Maricopa County Recorder's Office against the lot. This lien is now part of the public record and will appear in any title search.
- Notice of intent to foreclose: If the lien remains unpaid, the HOA provides statutory notice of intent to foreclose. The homeowner has an opportunity to cure (pay all amounts owed including fees and costs) to stop the foreclosure.
- Foreclosure filing: HOA initiates formal foreclosure proceedings. In Arizona, this typically proceeds as a trustee's sale process.
- Trustee's sale: If the homeowner does not cure the default, the property is sold at trustee's sale. Total timeline from initial delinquency to sale: typically 6–18 months.
The Right Response to HOA Financial Hardship
If you are experiencing financial hardship that makes it difficult to pay HOA assessments on time, the most important thing you can do is contact the HOA management company proactively — before the account becomes severely delinquent. Arizona HOAs strongly prefer payment plans over foreclosure proceedings. Foreclosure is expensive, time-consuming, and publicly visible. Most HOA management companies are authorized to negotiate payment plans for homeowners who communicate their situation in good faith.
Key principles for managing HOA financial hardship:
- Contact the HOA management company in writing before the account is referred to collections
- Propose a specific, realistic payment plan with a defined payoff timeline
- Follow through on the payment plan exactly as agreed
- If you receive a lien notice, consult a real estate attorney immediately about your rights to cure the lien before foreclosure proceeds
- Never ignore HOA communications — silence accelerates the collection timeline
HOA vs Non-HOA — Practical Guidance for Choosing the Right Community
One of the most valuable conversations Ryan has with buyers is helping them think clearly about whether an HOA community is actually the right fit for their lifestyle and priorities — before they fall in love with a home and discover the HOA restrictions are incompatible with how they live. This decision framework applies to buyers throughout Phoenix metro, East Valley, and Scottsdale.
Who HOA Communities Tend to Serve Well
Value consistent neighborhood maintenance standards across all properties. Want amenities (pool, fitness center, parks) without the individual cost and responsibility of owning them. Travel frequently and value HOA enforcement of maintenance standards on neighbors. Are buying in the $500K+ range in Phoenix metro (most homes at this price point are in HOAs). Want guard-gated security or a luxury resort lifestyle. Are relocating and want a community environment that feels managed and maintained from day one.
Park an RV, boat, work truck, or multiple personal vehicles at home and need driveway access. Run a business with visible equipment, signage, or commercial vehicles. Have strong landscaping preferences (vegetable gardens, non-standard plants, unique hardscape). Plan to rent the property short-term. Have an ADU or plan to add a casita and want maximum ADU flexibility. Want to paint your home any color you choose. Simply want lower monthly carrying costs and fewer rules governing your property use.
Where to Find Non-HOA Properties in Phoenix Metro
Non-HOA single-family homes exist in the Phoenix metro, but they are concentrated in older neighborhoods that predate the master-planned community era. The primary inventory locations for non-HOA properties:
- Midtown Phoenix and Central Phoenix: Neighborhoods like Willo Historic District, Windsor Square, Campus Vista, and Encanto Park area have significant non-HOA inventory.
- Arcadia and Arcadia Lite: The desirable Arcadia area (between Phoenix, Scottsdale, and Tempe) has many non-HOA homes, though some sub-areas have HOAs. Arcadia Lite (south Arcadia) has significant non-HOA inventory.
- Original Mesa and Tempe: Older neighborhoods in central Mesa and Tempe (pre-1990 development) are largely non-HOA.
- South Scottsdale: The older, southern portions of Scottsdale (south of Indian School Road) have non-HOA neighborhoods.
- Original Chandler and Gilbert cores: The oldest parts of downtown Chandler and older Gilbert neighborhoods predate the master-planned HOA era.
Non-HOA properties in desirable Phoenix metro locations often command a premium among buyers who specifically want that flexibility. Supply is constrained because virtually all new construction in the metro builds under HOA governance, meaning the non-HOA inventory base does not expand meaningfully. Ryan can specifically identify non-HOA inventory in any target area as part of buyer search criteria for buyers who want that flexibility as a priority.
Ryan reviews HOA documents as a substantive part of the due diligence process on every HOA purchase he manages for buyers. This means actually reading the CC&Rs, reviewing the financial statements for pending assessments and reserve adequacy, flagging any provision that conflicts with the buyer's stated plans for the property, and advising the buyer whether the HOA document package reveals any red flags that should affect the price or terms of the transaction. The Arizona Residential Purchase Contract provides a right to cancel based on HOA document review — this right is meaningless if the documents are not actually reviewed. Every buyer who works with Ryan understands the HOA they are buying into before they remove their inspection contingency.